{ "timestamp": "2026-03-29 06:11:18", "testcases": { "Button Persistence": [ { "step": "Setup", "check": "clear", "status": "PASS", "detail": "cleared" }, { "step": "Create buttons", "check": "send: create two buttons: Poodle Bark and Bolo", "status": "PASS", "detail": "response: Okay, I've created two buttons for you: \"Poodle Bark\" and \"Bolonka Bark\". 🐶 \n" }, { "step": "Create buttons", "check": "actions: length >= 2", "status": "PASS", "detail": "2 actions >= 2" }, { "step": "Create buttons", "check": "actions: any action contains \"poodle\" or \"Poodle\"", "status": "PASS", "detail": "found 'poodle' in actions" }, { "step": "Create buttons", "check": "actions: any action contains \"bolonka\" or \"Bolonka\"", "status": "PASS", "detail": "found 'bolonka' in actions" }, { "step": "Ask unrelated question (buttons must survive)", "check": "send: what time is it?", "status": "PASS", "detail": "response: The current time is 6:08 AM. ⏰\n" }, { "step": "Ask unrelated question (buttons must survive)", "check": "response: contains \":\" or \"time\" or \"clock\"", "status": "PASS", "detail": "found ':'" }, { "step": "Ask unrelated question (buttons must survive)", "check": "actions: any action contains \"poodle\" or \"Poodle\"", "status": "PASS", "detail": "found 'poodle' in actions" }, { "step": "Ask unrelated question (buttons must survive)", "check": "actions: any action contains \"bolonka\" or \"Bolonka\"", "status": "PASS", "detail": "found 'bolonka' in actions" }, { "step": "Ask another question (buttons still there)", "check": "send: say hello in German", "status": "PASS", "detail": "response: Hallo! 👋\n" }, { "step": "Ask another question (buttons still there)", "check": "response: contains \"Hallo\" or \"hallo\" or \"German\"", "status": "PASS", "detail": "found 'Hallo'" }, { "step": "Ask another question (buttons still there)", "check": "actions: any action contains \"poodle\" or \"Poodle\"", "status": "PASS", "detail": "found 'poodle' in actions" }, { "step": "Explicitly replace buttons", "check": "send: remove all buttons and create one button", "status": "PASS", "detail": "response: You got it! I've removed the existing buttons and created a single button labele" }, { "step": "Explicitly replace buttons", "check": "actions: length >= 1", "status": "PASS", "detail": "1 actions >= 1" }, { "step": "Explicitly replace buttons", "check": "actions: any action contains \"reset\" or \"Reset\"", "status": "PASS", "detail": "found 'reset' in actions" } ], "Counter State": [ { "step": "Setup", "check": "clear", "status": "PASS", "detail": "cleared" }, { "step": "Create counter", "check": "send: create a counter starting at 0 with incr", "status": "PASS", "detail": "response: " }, { "step": "Create counter", "check": "response: contains \"counter\" or \"count\"", "status": "FAIL", "detail": "none of ['counter', 'count'] found in: " }, { "step": "Create counter", "check": "actions: length >= 2", "status": "FAIL", "detail": "1 actions < 2" }, { "step": "Create counter", "check": "actions: any action contains \"increment\" or \"inc\" or \"plus\" or \"add\"", "status": "FAIL", "detail": "none of ['increment', 'inc', 'plus', 'add'] found in 1 buttons" }, { "step": "Create counter", "check": "actions: any action contains \"decrement\" or \"dec\" or \"minus\" or \"sub\"", "status": "FAIL", "detail": "none of ['decrement', 'dec', 'minus', 'sub'] found in 1 buttons" }, { "step": "Check state", "check": "state: topic contains \"counter\" or \"count\" or \"button\"", "status": "FAIL", "detail": "topic=UI creation doesn't contain any of ['counter', 'count', 'button']" }, { "step": "Ask for current value", "check": "send: what is the current count?", "status": "PASS", "detail": "response: " }, { "step": "Ask for current value", "check": "response: contains \"0\" or \"zero\"", "status": "FAIL", "detail": "none of ['0', 'zero'] found in: " }, { "step": "Increment", "check": "action matching 'inc'", "status": "FAIL", "detail": "no action matching 'inc' in ['reset']" }, { "step": "Increment", "check": "response: contains \"1\" or \"one\" or \"increment\" or \"Navigated\"", "status": "FAIL", "detail": "none of ['1', 'one', 'increment', 'Navigated'] found in: " }, { "step": "Increment again", "check": "action matching 'inc'", "status": "FAIL", "detail": "no action matching 'inc' in ['reset']" }, { "step": "Increment again", "check": "response: contains \"2\" or \"two\" or \"increment\" or \"Navigated\"", "status": "FAIL", "detail": "none of ['2', 'two', 'increment', 'Navigated'] found in: " }, { "step": "Decrement", "check": "action matching 'dec'", "status": "FAIL", "detail": "no action matching 'dec' in ['reset']" }, { "step": "Decrement", "check": "response: contains \"1\" or \"one\" or \"decrement\" or \"Navigated\"", "status": "FAIL", "detail": "none of ['1', 'one', 'decrement', 'Navigated'] found in: " }, { "step": "Verify memorizer tracks it", "check": "state: topic contains \"count\"", "status": "FAIL", "detail": "topic=UI creation doesn't contain any of ['count']" } ], "DB Exploration": [ { "step": "Setup", "check": "clear", "status": "PASS", "detail": "cleared" }, { "step": "Query renders table in workspace", "check": "send: show me 5 customers from the database", "status": "PASS", "detail": "response: " }, { "step": "Query renders table in workspace", "check": "trace: has tool_call", "status": "FAIL", "detail": "no 'tool_call' event in trace" }, { "step": "Query renders table in workspace", "check": "actions: has table", "status": "FAIL", "detail": "no table in 1 controls" }, { "step": "Query renders table in workspace", "check": "response: not contains \"---|\" or \"| ID\"", "status": "PASS", "detail": "none of ['---|', '| ID'] found (as expected)" }, { "step": "Chat summarizes, does not dump data", "check": "response: contains \"customer\" or \"Kunde\" or \"5\" or \"table\"", "status": "FAIL", "detail": "none of ['customer', 'Kunde', '5', 'table'] found in: " }, { "step": "Chat summarizes, does not dump data", "check": "response: length > 10", "status": "FAIL", "detail": "length 0 <= 10" }, { "step": "Thinker builds exploration UI (not describes it)", "check": "send: select customer 2 Kathrin Jager, add but", "status": "PASS", "detail": "response: " }, { "step": "Thinker builds exploration UI (not describes it)", "check": "actions: length >= 1", "status": "PASS", "detail": "1 actions >= 1" }, { "step": "Thinker builds exploration UI (not describes it)", "check": "response: not contains \"UI team\" or \"will add\" or \"will create\"", "status": "PASS", "detail": "none of ['UI team', 'will add', 'will create'] found (as expected)" }, { "step": "Error recovery on bad query", "check": "send: SELECT * FROM nichtexistiert LIMIT 5", "status": "PASS", "detail": "response: " }, { "step": "Error recovery on bad query", "check": "trace: has tool_call", "status": "FAIL", "detail": "no 'tool_call' event in trace" }, { "step": "Error recovery on bad query", "check": "response: not contains \"1146\"", "status": "PASS", "detail": "none of ['1146'] found (as expected)" }, { "step": "Error recovery on bad query", "check": "response: length > 10", "status": "FAIL", "detail": "length 0 <= 10" } ], "Director Node": [ { "step": "Setup", "check": "clear", "status": "PASS", "detail": "cleared" }, { "step": "Casual chat establishes mode", "check": "send: hey, just hanging out, what's up?", "status": "PASS", "detail": "response: " }, { "step": "Casual chat establishes mode", "check": "response: length > 5", "status": "FAIL", "detail": "length 0 <= 5" }, { "step": "Casual chat establishes mode", "check": "trace: has director_updated", "status": "PASS", "detail": "found event 'director_updated'" }, { "step": "Director picks up frustration", "check": "send: ugh this is so annoying, nothing makes s", "status": "PASS", "detail": "response: " }, { "step": "Director picks up frustration", "check": "response: length > 10", "status": "FAIL", "detail": "length 0 <= 10" }, { "step": "Director picks up frustration", "check": "trace: has director_updated", "status": "PASS", "detail": "found event 'director_updated'" }, { "step": "Switch to building mode", "check": "send: ok let's build a todo list app", "status": "PASS", "detail": "response: " }, { "step": "Switch to building mode", "check": "response: length > 10", "status": "FAIL", "detail": "length 0 <= 10" }, { "step": "Switch to building mode", "check": "trace: has director_updated", "status": "PASS", "detail": "found event 'director_updated'" } ], "Pub Conversation": [ { "step": "Setup", "check": "clear", "status": "PASS", "detail": "cleared" }, { "step": "Set the scene", "check": "send: Hey, Alice and I are heading to the pub ", "status": "PASS", "detail": "response: " }, { "step": "Set the scene", "check": "response: length > 10", "status": "FAIL", "detail": "length 0 <= 10" }, { "step": "Set the scene", "check": "state: situation contains \"pub\" or \"Alice\"", "status": "FAIL", "detail": "situation=local session doesn't contain any of ['pub', 'Alice']" }, { "step": "Language switch to German", "check": "send: Wir sind jetzt im Biergarten angekommen", "status": "PASS", "detail": "response: " }, { "step": "Language switch to German", "check": "response: length > 10", "status": "FAIL", "detail": "length 0 <= 10" }, { "step": "Language switch to German", "check": "state: language is \"de\" or \"mixed\"", "status": "PASS", "detail": "language=mixed" }, { "step": "Context awareness", "check": "send: Was sollen wir bestellen?", "status": "PASS", "detail": "response: " }, { "step": "Context awareness", "check": "response: length > 10", "status": "FAIL", "detail": "length 0 <= 10" }, { "step": "Context awareness", "check": "state: topic contains \"bestell\" or \"order\" or \"pub\" or \"Biergarten\"", "status": "FAIL", "detail": "topic=UI creation doesn't contain any of ['bestell', 'order', 'pub', 'Biergarten']" }, { "step": "Alice speaks", "check": "send: Alice says: I'll have a Hefeweizen pleas", "status": "PASS", "detail": "response: " }, { "step": "Alice speaks", "check": "response: length > 10", "status": "FAIL", "detail": "length 0 <= 10" }, { "step": "Alice speaks", "check": "state: facts any contains \"Alice\" or \"Hefeweizen\"", "status": "FAIL", "detail": "none of ['Alice', 'Hefeweizen'] found in facts: []" }, { "step": "Ask for time (tool use)", "check": "send: wie spaet ist es eigentlich?", "status": "PASS", "detail": "response: " }, { "step": "Ask for time (tool use)", "check": "response: matches \\d{1,2}:\\d{2}", "status": "FAIL", "detail": "/\\d{1,2}:\\d{2}/ not found in: " }, { "step": "Back to English", "check": "send: Let's switch to English, what was the la", "status": "PASS", "detail": "response: " }, { "step": "Back to English", "check": "state: language is \"en\" or \"mixed\"", "status": "PASS", "detail": "language=mixed" }, { "step": "Back to English", "check": "response: contains \"Alice\" or \"Hefeweizen\"", "status": "FAIL", "detail": "none of ['Alice', 'Hefeweizen'] found in: " }, { "step": "Mood check", "check": "send: This is really fun!", "status": "PASS", "detail": "response: " }, { "step": "Mood check", "check": "state: user_mood is \"happy\" or \"playful\" or \"excited\"", "status": "FAIL", "detail": "user_mood=neutral not in ['happy', 'playful', 'excited']" } ], "Reflex Path": [ { "step": "Setup", "check": "clear", "status": "PASS", "detail": "cleared" }, { "step": "Greeting triggers reflex", "check": "send: hey!", "status": "PASS", "detail": "response: " }, { "step": "Greeting triggers reflex", "check": "response: length > 2", "status": "FAIL", "detail": "length 0 <= 2" }, { "step": "Greeting triggers reflex", "check": "trace: has reflex_path", "status": "FAIL", "detail": "no 'reflex_path' event in trace" }, { "step": "Thanks triggers reflex", "check": "send: thanks", "status": "PASS", "detail": "response: " }, { "step": "Thanks triggers reflex", "check": "response: length > 2", "status": "FAIL", "detail": "length 0 <= 2" }, { "step": "Thanks triggers reflex", "check": "trace: has reflex_path", "status": "FAIL", "detail": "no 'reflex_path' event in trace" }, { "step": "Complex request does NOT trigger reflex", "check": "send: explain how neural networks work in deta", "status": "PASS", "detail": "response: " }, { "step": "Complex request does NOT trigger reflex", "check": "response: length > 20", "status": "FAIL", "detail": "length 0 <= 20" }, { "step": "Complex request does NOT trigger reflex", "check": "trace: input.analysis.intent is \"question\" or \"request\"", "status": "PASS", "detail": "input.analysis.intent=request" }, { "step": "Complex request does NOT trigger reflex", "check": "trace: has decided", "status": "FAIL", "detail": "no 'decided' event in trace" } ], "S3* Audit Corrections": [ { "step": "Setup", "check": "clear", "status": "PASS", "detail": "cleared" }, { "step": "Tool calls produce results (baseline)", "check": "send: create two buttons: Alpha and Beta", "status": "PASS", "detail": "response: " }, { "step": "Tool calls produce results (baseline)", "check": "actions: length >= 1", "status": "PASS", "detail": "1 actions >= 1" }, { "step": "Tool calls produce results (baseline)", "check": "actions: any action contains \"alpha\" or \"Alpha\"", "status": "FAIL", "detail": "none of ['alpha', 'Alpha'] found in 1 buttons" }, { "step": "Dashboard mismatch triggers re-emit", "check": "send: I see nothing on my dashboard, fix it", "status": "PASS", "detail": "response: " }, { "step": "Dashboard mismatch triggers re-emit", "check": "response: not contains \"sorry\" or \"apologize\"", "status": "PASS", "detail": "none of ['sorry', 'apologize'] found (as expected)" }, { "step": "Dashboard mismatch triggers re-emit", "check": "actions: length >= 1", "status": "PASS", "detail": "1 actions >= 1" }, { "step": "DB error triggers retry with corrected SQL", "check": "send: SELECT * FROM NichtExistent LIMIT 5", "status": "PASS", "detail": "response: " }, { "step": "DB error triggers retry with corrected SQL", "check": "trace: has tool_call", "status": "FAIL", "detail": "no 'tool_call' event in trace" }, { "step": "DB error triggers retry with corrected SQL", "check": "response: not contains \"1146\"", "status": "PASS", "detail": "none of ['1146'] found (as expected)" }, { "step": "DB error triggers retry with corrected SQL", "check": "response: length > 10", "status": "FAIL", "detail": "length 0 <= 10" }, { "step": "Complex request gets Director plan", "check": "send: investigate which customers have the mos", "status": "PASS", "detail": "response: " }, { "step": "Complex request gets Director plan", "check": "trace: has director_plan", "status": "FAIL", "detail": "no 'director_plan' event in trace" }, { "step": "Complex request gets Director plan", "check": "trace: has tool_call", "status": "FAIL", "detail": "no 'tool_call' event in trace" }, { "step": "Complex request gets Director plan", "check": "response: length > 20", "status": "FAIL", "detail": "length 0 <= 20" } ], "State Machines": [ { "step": "Setup", "check": "clear", "status": "PASS", "detail": "cleared" }, { "step": "Create a machine", "check": "send: create a navigation machine called \"nav\"", "status": "PASS", "detail": "response: " }, { "step": "Create a machine", "check": "trace: has tool_call create_machine", "status": "FAIL", "detail": "no tool_call 'create_machine' in trace" }, { "step": "Create a machine", "check": "trace: machine_created id=\"nav\"", "status": "FAIL", "detail": "no machine_created event with id='nav'" }, { "step": "Verify machine renders", "check": "send: what machines are on my dashboard?", "status": "PASS", "detail": "response: " }, { "step": "Verify machine renders", "check": "response: contains \"nav\" or \"machine\"", "status": "FAIL", "detail": "none of ['nav', 'machine'] found in: " }, { "step": "Navigate via button click (local transition)", "check": "action matching 'menu_1'", "status": "FAIL", "detail": "no action matching 'menu_1' in ['reset']" }, { "step": "Navigate via button click (local transition)", "check": "trace: has machine_transition", "status": "FAIL", "detail": "no 'machine_transition' event in trace" }, { "step": "Navigate via button click (local transition)", "check": "trace: no thinker", "status": "PASS", "detail": "no 'thinker' event (as expected)" }, { "step": "Add a state to existing machine", "check": "send: add a state \"sub3\" to the nav machine wi", "status": "PASS", "detail": "response: " }, { "step": "Add a state to existing machine", "check": "trace: has tool_call add_state", "status": "FAIL", "detail": "no tool_call 'add_state' in trace" }, { "step": "Reset machine", "check": "send: reset the nav machine to its initial sta", "status": "PASS", "detail": "response: " }, { "step": "Reset machine", "check": "trace: has tool_call reset_machine", "status": "FAIL", "detail": "no tool_call 'reset_machine' in trace" }, { "step": "Reset machine", "check": "response: contains \"main\" or \"reset\" or \"initial\"", "status": "FAIL", "detail": "none of ['main', 'reset', 'initial'] found in: " }, { "step": "Create second machine alongside first", "check": "send: create a counter machine called \"clicks\"", "status": "PASS", "detail": "response: " }, { "step": "Create second machine alongside first", "check": "trace: has tool_call create_machine", "status": "FAIL", "detail": "no tool_call 'create_machine' in trace" }, { "step": "Create second machine alongside first", "check": "trace: machine_created id=\"clicks\"", "status": "FAIL", "detail": "no machine_created event with id='clicks'" }, { "step": "Both machines coexist", "check": "send: what machines are running?", "status": "PASS", "detail": "response: " }, { "step": "Both machines coexist", "check": "response: contains \"nav\"", "status": "FAIL", "detail": "none of ['nav'] found in: " }, { "step": "Both machines coexist", "check": "response: contains \"click\"", "status": "FAIL", "detail": "none of ['click'] found in: " }, { "step": "Destroy one machine", "check": "send: destroy the clicks machine", "status": "PASS", "detail": "response: " }, { "step": "Destroy one machine", "check": "trace: has tool_call destroy_machine", "status": "FAIL", "detail": "no tool_call 'destroy_machine' in trace" }, { "step": "Destroy one machine", "check": "send: what machines are running?", "status": "PASS", "detail": "response: " }, { "step": "Destroy one machine", "check": "response: contains \"nav\"", "status": "FAIL", "detail": "none of ['nav'] found in: " } ], "Structured Input Analysis": [ { "step": "Setup", "check": "clear", "status": "PASS", "detail": "cleared" }, { "step": "Social greeting", "check": "send: hi there!", "status": "PASS", "detail": "response: " }, { "step": "Social greeting", "check": "response: length > 3", "status": "FAIL", "detail": "length 0 <= 3" }, { "step": "Social greeting", "check": "trace: input.analysis.intent is \"social\"", "status": "FAIL", "detail": "input.analysis.intent=request, expected one of ['social']" }, { "step": "Social greeting", "check": "trace: input.analysis.complexity is \"trivial\"", "status": "FAIL", "detail": "input.analysis.complexity=simple, expected one of ['trivial']" }, { "step": "Simple request", "check": "send: create a counter starting at 0", "status": "PASS", "detail": "response: " }, { "step": "Simple request", "check": "response: length > 10", "status": "FAIL", "detail": "length 0 <= 10" }, { "step": "Simple request", "check": "trace: input.analysis.intent is \"request\" or \"action\"", "status": "PASS", "detail": "input.analysis.intent=request" }, { "step": "Simple request", "check": "trace: input.analysis.complexity is \"simple\" or \"complex\"", "status": "PASS", "detail": "input.analysis.complexity=simple" }, { "step": "German question", "check": "send: Wie spaet ist es?", "status": "PASS", "detail": "response: " }, { "step": "German question", "check": "response: length > 5", "status": "FAIL", "detail": "length 0 <= 5" }, { "step": "German question", "check": "trace: input.analysis.language is \"de\"", "status": "FAIL", "detail": "input.analysis.language=en, expected one of ['de']" }, { "step": "German question", "check": "trace: input.analysis.intent is \"question\"", "status": "FAIL", "detail": "input.analysis.intent=request, expected one of ['question']" }, { "step": "Frustrated tone", "check": "send: this is broken, nothing works and I'm si", "status": "PASS", "detail": "response: " }, { "step": "Frustrated tone", "check": "response: length > 10", "status": "FAIL", "detail": "length 0 <= 10" }, { "step": "Frustrated tone", "check": "trace: input.analysis.tone is \"frustrated\" or \"urgent\"", "status": "FAIL", "detail": "input.analysis.tone=casual, expected one of ['frustrated', 'urgent']" }, { "step": "Simple acknowledgment", "check": "send: ok thanks bye", "status": "PASS", "detail": "response: " }, { "step": "Simple acknowledgment", "check": "trace: input.analysis.intent is \"social\"", "status": "FAIL", "detail": "input.analysis.intent=request, expected one of ['social']" }, { "step": "Simple acknowledgment", "check": "trace: input.analysis.complexity is \"trivial\"", "status": "FAIL", "detail": "input.analysis.complexity=simple, expected one of ['trivial']" } ], "Dashboard Feedback (S3*)": [ { "step": "Setup", "check": "clear", "status": "PASS", "detail": "cleared" }, { "step": "Thinker sees buttons in dashboard", "check": "send: create two buttons: hello and world", "status": "PASS", "detail": "response: " }, { "step": "Thinker sees buttons in dashboard", "check": "actions: length >= 2", "status": "FAIL", "detail": "1 actions < 2" }, { "step": "Thinker sees buttons in dashboard", "check": "send: what buttons can you see in my dashboard", "status": "PASS", "detail": "response: " }, { "step": "Thinker sees buttons in dashboard", "check": "response: contains \"Hello\" or \"hello\"", "status": "FAIL", "detail": "none of ['Hello', 'hello'] found in: " }, { "step": "Thinker sees buttons in dashboard", "check": "response: contains \"World\" or \"world\"", "status": "FAIL", "detail": "none of ['World', 'world'] found in: " }, { "step": "Thinker detects empty dashboard", "check": "send: I see nothing in my dashboard, what happ", "status": "PASS", "detail": "response: " }, { "step": "Thinker detects empty dashboard", "check": "response: contains \"button\" or \"fix\" or \"restore\" or \"create\" or \"empty\"", "status": "FAIL", "detail": "none of ['button', 'fix', 'restore', 'create', 'empty'] found in: " }, { "step": "Dashboard state flows to thinker context", "check": "send: create a counter starting at 5", "status": "PASS", "detail": "response: " }, { "step": "Dashboard state flows to thinker context", "check": "actions: length >= 1", "status": "PASS", "detail": "1 actions >= 1" }, { "step": "Dashboard state flows to thinker context", "check": "send: what does my dashboard show?", "status": "PASS", "detail": "response: " }, { "step": "Dashboard state flows to thinker context", "check": "response: contains \"5\" or \"count\"", "status": "FAIL", "detail": "none of ['5', 'count'] found in: " } ], "Dashboard Mismatch Recovery": [ { "step": "Setup", "check": "clear", "status": "PASS", "detail": "cleared" }, { "step": "Create buttons", "check": "send: create two buttons: red and blue", "status": "PASS", "detail": "response: " }, { "step": "Create buttons", "check": "actions: length >= 2", "status": "FAIL", "detail": "1 actions < 2" }, { "step": "Dashboard empty — Thinker re-emits", "check": "send: I clicked red but nothing happened", "status": "PASS", "detail": "response: " }, { "step": "Dashboard empty — Thinker re-emits", "check": "response: contains \"button\" or \"red\" or \"blue\"", "status": "FAIL", "detail": "none of ['button', 'red', 'blue'] found in: " }, { "step": "Dashboard empty — Thinker re-emits", "check": "actions: length >= 1", "status": "PASS", "detail": "1 actions >= 1" }, { "step": "Create counter", "check": "send: create a counter starting at 0", "status": "PASS", "detail": "response: " }, { "step": "Create counter", "check": "actions: length >= 1", "status": "PASS", "detail": "1 actions >= 1" }, { "step": "Counter missing from dashboard — Thinker recovers", "check": "send: the dashboard is broken, I only see old ", "status": "PASS", "detail": "response: " }, { "step": "Counter missing from dashboard — Thinker recovers", "check": "response: contains \"counter\" or \"count\" or \"fix\" or \"recreat\" or \"refresh\" or \"button\" or \"update\"", "status": "FAIL", "detail": "none of ['counter', 'count', 'fix', 'recreat', 'refresh', 'button', 'update'] found in: " }, { "step": "Counter missing from dashboard — Thinker recovers", "check": "actions: length >= 1", "status": "PASS", "detail": "1 actions >= 1" } ] }, "summary": { "passed": 90, "failed": 77 } }